The health insurance industry is notably intricate, with companies operating in various niches to provide scalable solutions for diverse needs. In Ohio, the industry is flourishing as it houses numerous individual health insurance companies, each providing an array of services. These companies offer comprehensive plans that cater to different individuals and their families, with options ranging from affordable premiums to extensive healthcare provisions. With the rising healthcare costs, these companies are focused on delivering quality, affordable health insurance while prioritizing the welfare of their clients. As the Industry progresses, it leans towards innovative models that guarantee fair pricing, cost control, and employer-specific customization.


Top 20 individual health insurance companies in Ohio

1. HealthSpan Ohio

HealthSpan is a healthcare company that provides healthcare coverage. They offer comprehensive healthcare services to individuals and families.


2. Roundstone

Roundstone Insurance offers affordable and quality health insurance solutions for small to mid-size employers. They provide a self-funded insurance model that allows employers to save money and have more control over their healthcare costs. With Roundstone Insurance, employers can customize their plans and save up to 20% or more.


3. Vitori Health

  • Website: vitorihealth.com
  • Headquarters: Boston-Cleveland-Charleston-Kansas City, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2020
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Series Unknown
  • LinkedIn

Vitori Health is a company that offers quality alternatives to outdated employer-sponsored health insurance plans. They focus on maximizing savings and cost control while providing comprehensive health benefits and high-touch member support. Their approach removes excess costs and waste from health plan benefits, allowing employers to gain durable control over cost and value.


4. Ohio Health Benefits LLC

Ohio Health Benefits is a locally-owned and operated independent insurance broker that offers group insurance and individual/family health insurance. They provide outstanding service and support for the insurance products they sell, helping clients find the best fit for their unique situation and budget.


5. ARC Benefit Solutions

ARC Benefit Solutions is a company that specializes in providing customized health insurance solutions. They strive to find a balance between benefits and budget, ensuring their clients feel confident in their decision. With a focus on peace of mind, ARC puts their clients first, providing trusted relationships and simplifying the insurance process.


6. Financial Educational Systems

  • Website: fesmm.com
  • Headquarters: Cincinnati, Ohio, United States
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Financial Educational Systems is a company that offers resources and services to help individuals understand and manage their finances. They provide calculators, research reports, and newsletter articles to assist with cash flow analysis, retirement planning, insurance, investing, and estate planning.


7. InsureOne Benefits

InsureOne Benefits is an all-in-one Medicare solution company that helps clients maximize their options and navigate their health insurance with personalized guidance.


8. Medical Mutual

  • Website: medmutual.com
  • Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1934
  • Headcount: 1001-5000
  • LinkedIn

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurance company that offers a range of insurance plans including Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Employer Group plans. They provide coverage for individual and family needs, specializing in health insurance solutions.


9. AultCare

  • Website: aultcare.com
  • Headquarters: Canton, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1985
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn

AultCare is a health insurance company that offers personalized customer service and customized plans for employers. They provide access to quality healthcare with a focus on keeping individuals healthy and helping them when they're not. They offer a wide network of in-network hospitals and telehealth services.


10. McGohan Brabender

McGohan Brabender is a Midwest-based company with 200 employee owners that specializes in building benefits packages for employers. They offer a range of solutions including access to care advocacy, brokerage, and consulting services, compliance and health care reform, data analytics and reporting, HR technology, incentive strategies, individual medical and retiree benefits, self-funding options, and worksite benefits.


11. Sheakley Benefit Plans

At Sheakley Benefit Plans, we offer traditional and innovative programs and strategies. We are committed to staying on top of the ever-changing market by continually researching and monitoring products and companies. We do our best to help you protect what you have and build for the future.


12. HEMA: Health Enrollment Management Agency

  • Website: hemahelp.com
  • Headquarters: Westerville, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2013
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

HEMA Health Enrollment Management Agency offers a range of healthcare plans including fixed indemnity, hospital expense, accident expense, and individual health plans. They also offer telemedicine, vision and dental plans, and cancer, heart & stroke coverage.


13. Health & Life Insurance Agent

EasyToInsureME is a one-stop solution for senior insurance needs, offering Medicare supplements and advantage plans, as well as senior dental and vision coverage.


14. Wirt Cain Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent

Wirt Cain is an insurance provider in Broadview Heights, OH offering auto, business, personal property, life and health insurance policies. They offer customizable plans to help protect families, individuals, and companies from potential risks.


15. CareSource

Caresource is a company that offers comprehensive healthcare solutions to individuals, families, and businesses. They provide a wide range of insurance plans, including medical, dental, and vision coverage. Caresource is committed to improving the health and well-being of their customers by offering affordable and accessible healthcare options.


16. Buckeye Health Plan

Buckeye Health Plan is a healthcare company that offers Medicaid, Medicare Advantage, and Health Insurance Marketplace plans. They provide coverage for a wide range of healthcare services and aim to improve the lives of their members through high-quality and accessible healthcare.


17. SummaCare

SummaCare is a healthcare company that offers a range of health plans and services. They prioritize the health and safety of their members and provide solutions to common health conditions. SummaCare empowers individuals to take charge of their health through preventive screenings and regular health exams. They also offer Medicare plans and pharmacy benefits. The company focuses on improving the quality of healthcare services and ensuring optimal health for their customers.


18. Horan

HORAN is a financial services company that specializes in providing benefits for employees and managing healthcare costs. They offer services such as health benefits, retirement plan consulting, executive benefits, succession planning, and wealth management.


19. KAZ Company

  • Website: medicareplansneo.com
  • Headquarters: Independence, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2010
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

MEDICARE ADVANTAGE PLANS: KAZ Company offers a range of Medicare Advantage Plans to individuals turning 65, going on Medicare, and/or retiring. They provide information and educate clients on their Medicare options. Please note that they do not offer every plan available in all areas.


20. Ohio Laborers Benefits

Ohio Laborers Benefits is an insurance and pension provider founded in 1967. They offer comprehensive health and welfare coverage for eligible members, including a PPO network, prescription drug benefits, vision care, hearing aid benefits, accidental death & dismemberment benefits, and short term disability benefits. Retiree insurance is also available. They also provide pension plans and have a range of contractor relations services.


Want to find more individual health insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer unique health coverage solutions catering to divergent needs you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!