The Medicare supplement insurance industry in Ohio is diverse and vital. These companies cater to a wide demographic, offering much-needed financial reprieve during medical emergencies. From large, established insurance providers to smaller, specialized firms, they all present a variety of coverage plans to suit individual needs. These companies not only provide Medicare supplement plans but also offer comprehensive health, life, and employer group insurance plans. As the population continues to age, these plans become more in-demand, making these companies an increasingly important aspect of Ohio's healthcare system. Locally based, they are able to use their intricate understanding of Ohio's healthcare landscape to tailor plans that best benefit the Ohioans they serve.


Top 20 medicare supplement insurance companies in Ohio

1. Medical Mutual

  • Website: medmutual.com
  • Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1934
  • Headcount: 1001-5000
  • LinkedIn

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurance company that offers a range of insurance plans including Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Employer Group plans. They provide coverage for individual and family needs, specializing in health insurance solutions.


2. Medicare Resource Center

MedicareOH.com is a Medicare Resource Center based in Columbus, Ohio. They offer assistance in finding Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage and Medigap Insurance. Their expert agents provide guidance on Medicare Advantage Plans and help navigate the complexities of Medicare. They aim to find the best plan that fits the customer's needs and offer their services for free.


3. Harmon Insurance Brokerage, LLC

Harmon Insurance Brokerage is a leading provider of insurance solutions in Southeastern Ohio since 1980. They offer comprehensive insurance coverage such as Individual and Group Health Insurance, Life Insurance, and Medicare Supplements.


4. Health & Life Insurance Agent

EasyToInsureME is a one-stop solution for senior insurance needs, offering Medicare supplements and advantage plans, as well as senior dental and vision coverage.


5. Myers Family Insurance

Myers Family Insurance is an insurance agency that specializes in providing insurance policies for Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage Plans, and Prescription Drug Plans.


6. KAZ Company

  • Website: medicareplansneo.com
  • Headquarters: Independence, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2010
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

MEDICARE ADVANTAGE PLANS: KAZ Company offers a range of Medicare Advantage Plans to individuals turning 65, going on Medicare, and/or retiring. They provide information and educate clients on their Medicare options. Please note that they do not offer every plan available in all areas.


7. DiStefano Insurance

  • Website: disagency.com
  • Headquarters: Canal Fulton, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1931
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

DiStefano Insurance Services Inc is an insurance agency based in Canal Fulton, Ohio. They offer a wide range of insurance products for both individuals and businesses. Their team is dedicated to providing excellent customer service and helping clients understand their insurance options. They work with multiple carriers to find the best coverage and cost combination for their clients.


8. LMS Insurance Group

LMS Benefits offers a full range of insurance services, including home insurance, health insurance, Medicare plans, life insurance, auto insurance, and business insurance. With strong relationships with insuring partners, they provide real human support and access to over 50 insurance companies. Customers can request a consultation and get the best rates in their area. LMS Benefits is dedicated to protecting individuals and their properties with personalized insurance solutions.


9. Your Medicare Plan Coach

Your Medicare Plan Coach is an independent insurance agency in Ohio, specializing in Medicare health and drug insurance plans from various carriers. They offer free consultation services.


10. United American Ins

United American Health insurance is an insurance provider to families, individuals, and seniors.


11. InsureOne Benefits

InsureOne Benefits is an all-in-one Medicare solution company that helps clients maximize their options and navigate their health insurance with personalized guidance.


12. RetireMed

  • Website: retiremed.com
  • Headquarters: Miamisburg, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2007
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

RetireMed is a Medicare advisory company that helps individuals and businesses navigate the complexities of Medicare. Our advisors provide personalized guidance to find the right plan based on unique needs, budget, and lifestyle, ensuring lifelong support at no cost. We offer clarity and assistance in understanding Medicare, eligibility, coverage, and costs.


13. Rankin & Rankin Insurance Services

Rankin & Rankin Insurance Services is an insurance agency based in Zanesville, Ohio. They offer a comprehensive array of personal and commercial insurance products, including employee benefits programs. With a focus on customer support and claims adjustment, they provide trusted coverage that fits specific needs.


14. Paige & Byrnes Insurance

Paige & Byrnes Insurance is a family-owned insurance agency serving Northeast Ohio. With exceptional customer service and outstanding relationships with the community, we offer a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions to protect individuals and businesses from the unexpected.


15. Northern Ohio Health and Wellness Benefits, LLC.

Northern Ohio Health and Wellness Benefits offers Medicare products and serves individuals and businesses in Ohio and Michigan.


16. Gem-Young Insurance & Wealth Advisors

  • Website: gemyoung.com
  • Headquarters: Canfield, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1947
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Gem-Young Insurance & Wealth Advisors is a local, family-owned independent insurance and financial planning agency that provides trusted advice and insurance solutions. They offer coverage for personal insurance, home insurance, life and accidental death insurance, as well as business insurance. With over 74 years of experience, they prioritize their clients' needs and provide professional advice at a fair value.


17. Albertson Lawrence Agency

Albertson Lawrence Agency is an independent insurance agency offering a range of insurance and financial solutions for individuals, families, and businesses in Coshocton, Ohio.


18. Classic Insurance & Financial Services Co.

MyMedicareInsider provides guidance and assistance on Medicare coverage options and helps customers make informed decisions on choosing the right Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans and Medicare Advantage Plans.


19. My Medicare Network

My Medicare Network is an insurance agency specializing in Medicare insurance for seniors that offers Medicare Advantage Plans, Medicare Supplement Plans, Dental Insurance Plans, and Prescription Drug Plans.


20. Cornerstone Insurance

All insurance, whether health, auto, life, or long-term care is a vehicle we use to not only protect our loved ones, but also the things we have worked for all our lives. As we age into different phases in life, its a nice feeling to have peace of mind, that no matter what life event may occur, we have prepared for it. Doesnt it make sense to protect not only our loved ones, but everything weve worked for all our lives? Cornerstone provides all the basic insurance products that youll need as you approach retirement age: Cornerstone believes in investing its time and resources into the local community. We know you have questions. Rest assure, Cornerstone Insurance has the answers. Whats the difference between a Medicare Supplement Plan and a Medicare Advantage Plan? How can insurance company offer a $0 premium plan? Which company has the best plan? As licensed insurance professionals, these are some of the questions we hear on a daily basis.


Want to find more medicare supplement insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer key services like Medicare Advantage, Prescription Drug Coverage and Medigap Insurance you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!