The auto insurance industry is an integral part of New York's insurance sector housing a wide array of companies providing vast coverage options for individual and commercial needs. With the primary function of risk protection for vehicles, these firms offer various packages including liability, comprehensive, collision, personal injury protection, and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Amid fluctuations in insurance costs, technological innovations, and changing regulatory landscapes, the industry's future may see more personalization of policies, further digital integration, and escalated automation in claims process.


Top 21 auto insurance companies in New York

1. Travelers

  • Website: travelers.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1853
  • Headcount: 10001+
  • Latest funding type: Ipo
  • LinkedIn

Travelers.com is an insurance company that offers coverage options for individuals and businesses. They provide a wide range of insurance services including auto, home, boat, and liability insurance. With a focus on risk management and customer satisfaction, Travelers.com helps customers protect their assets and adapt to changing circumstances.


2. National General

  • Website: nationalgeneral.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1920
  • Headcount: 5001-10000
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

National General, an Allstate company, provides coverage for vehicles, homes, and possessions. With a network of independent agents and a dedicated claims response team, they offer affordable insurance plans backed by attentive customer service and quick claim resolutions.


3. Utica National Insurance Group

Utica National is an insurance company that offers a range of personal and commercial insurance products such as auto, home, boat, motorcycle, and renters insurance. They also provide coverage for businesses, including small businesses, contractors, craft breweries, educational institutions, and more. With a focus on customer care and safety, they aim to provide reliable and comprehensive insurance solutions.


4. American Transit Insurance Co

American Transit Insurance Company provides specialized coverage for the livery and commercial auto industry in the New York City area. They offer insurance policies for independent tradespeople and corporations operating light-to-medium commercial trucks and non-medallion licensed livery vehicles. With a focus on trust, responsive service, fair pricing, and personal relationships, they are a leading writer of comprehensive insurance coverage for taxi fleets, owner/drivers, and individual owner/designated drivers.


5. TSC>Direct

Tri-State Consumer Insurance Company, now merged into Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company, offers insurance services in New York. With a rating of A- from A.M. Best, they provide auto and home insurance with easy policy renewal and 24-hour access through their self-service platform or mobile app. They offer discounted rates for employees through TSC Direct. Customers can file claims instantly, manage their policies online, and enjoy the convenience of online payment.


6. Gates-Cole Insurance

  • Website: gatescole.com
  • Headquarters: New Hartford, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1958
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Gates-Cole Insurance is an insurance company based in Central New York. They offer a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, business, and snowmobile insurance. With a team of knowledgeable agents, they provide excellent customer service and claims assistance. Their goal is to protect their customers' assets and provide them with the best rates and coverage possible.


7. Emerling, Floss, Murphy & Associates LLC

EFM Agency is an independent broker specializing in insurance and financial services. They offer personalized programs designed to provide ultimate protection for the best price. Their services include auto insurance, recreational vehicle insurance, homeowners insurance, health and life insurance, pet insurance, and commercial insurance.


8. Gerard P. Smith Insurance Agency

Rochester Insurance is an independent insurance agency that has been providing the best solutions for customers since 1966. They offer a wide range of commercial and personal insurance coverage, including auto, homeowners, business, and recreational vehicle insurance.


9. Acme Insurance Brokerage

My Acme Insurance offers auto, home, and commercial insurance policies to individuals and businesses. They also provide specialized insurance coverage such as umbrella insurance and boat/watercraft insurance. Their website allows customers to easily get quotes and make payments online.


10. Aegis Service Corp

Aegis Service Corp offers insurance products for personal automobile, homeowners, renters, recreational vehicle, and other property and liability needs. They provide efficient and reliable services with a team of experienced insurance professionals. Customers can expect personalized attention and quick response to their insurance needs.


11. bolt

  • Website: boltinsurance.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2000
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Series D
  • LinkedIn

Boltinsurance.com is a company that works with leading insurance industry players to bring insurance choices to customers. They offer a range of insurance products through their SaaS-based command center, bolt Exchange. Their offerings include access to direct appointments, additional insurance choices, and options to complement existing offerings. Boltinsurance.com aims to simplify insurance and help businesses deepen customer relationships, unlock new revenue streams, and expand their market reach.


12. Country-Wide Insurance Company

  • Website: cwico.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1963
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • Latest funding type: Ipo
  • LinkedIn

Country-Wide Insurance Company offers full one year policies with locked in rates. It provides installment payment options to policyholders and accepts various payment methods. Join the Family and take advantage of what Country-Wide offers.


13. Vault

Vault is an insurance company that offers specialized coverage for successful individuals and families. Their products are designed to protect valuable assets such as second homes, art collections, high-end appliances, and luxury vehicles. They prioritize a better customer experience, utilizing technology, thoughtful interactions, and unique solutions.


14. The Reis Group

Reis Insurance is an independent insurance agency that specializes in providing affordable and reliable insurance coverage for businesses and individuals in the Hudson Valley area of New York. They offer a wide range of insurance products, including home, auto, life, and business insurance. With their expertise, they help clients navigate the complexities of insurance products, cost, and compliance.


15. Day & Read an InsureOne Agency

  • Website: dayreadinc.com
  • Headquarters: Ilion, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2008
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Day & Read Inc. is the premier financial risk management company in Central New York. In addition, Day & Read is now part of the InsureOne of America family, one of the top 5 insurance brokers in the United States, who has continued to grow by successfully acquiring and integrating 100+ agencies since 2008. With a footprint of 26 locations in NYS alone, we have the ability to serve all clients they way you prefer, from a hometown agency perspective and feel.


16. Newbridge Coverage Corporation

Newbridge Coverage Corp. is an independent insurance agency based in Bellmore, NY. They offer a wide range of insurance services including personal auto insurance, boat insurance, health insurance, and more. With a focus on outstanding customer service, they aim to provide great coverage at competitive rates.


17. Infinity Auto Insurance

  • Website: infinityauto.com
  • Headquarters: Syracuse, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1955
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Infinity Auto is a company that offers a range of insurance products, including vehicle insurance, commercial insurance, property insurance, and other insurance options. They provide policies that protect individuals and businesses from various risks, with competitive prices and convenient online purchasing options.


18. Skeele Insurance Agency

  • Website: skeele.com
  • Headquarters: Deruyter, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1957
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Skeele is an independent insurance agency that offers a wide range of insurance products such as home, auto, farm, recreational vehicle, and life, investment, and health insurance. They represent multiple top-rated insurance companies, providing customers with the right coverage and great value. With the Skeele Insurance Agency app, customers can easily manage their policies, request changes or report claims, and make payments. The agency is known for its courteous, competent, and experienced staff who are quick to respond and answer all customer questions.


19. SEFCU Insurance Agency

SEFCU Insurance Agency offers a full range of insurance products such as auto, home, life, student benefits, and more, by working with multiple carriers to provide comparison shopping for customers.


20. Pearland Brokerage

Pearland Brokerage is a full-service insurance brokerage specializing in TLC Insurance for drivers of all major App Companies (including Via, Uber, Lyft), Black Cars, Car Service, Livery, Yellow Taxi Medallions, Green Cabs, Ambulette, Paratransit, and more. They offer both personal and commercial insurance products and have over 50 years of experience.


21. Insurance Information Institute

  • Website: iii.org
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1960
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Insurance Information Institute (iii.org) is a non-profit organization that provides objective, fact-based information about insurance. They aim to empower consumers by offering knowledge and resources to help them make educated decisions and manage risk.


Want to find more auto insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that provide coverage for a broad spectrum of vehicular risks you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!