The auto insurance industry in Minnesota is dominated by a mix of independent and direct insurance companies. These firms offer a broad array of coverage types, including comprehensive, third party, and specialized products that cater to specific needs such as boats or recreational vehicles. With the rise of digitization, many of these insurance providers are leveraging online platforms to deliver quick, user-friendly services. The future of this industry will likely see the continued evolution of digital offerings and a growing emphasis on tailored policies that meet individual customer requirements.


Top 22 auto insurance companies in Minnesota

1. Baxter Insurance Group

Baxter Insurance Group of Agents LLC is an independent insurance agency that offers a comprehensive line of quality coverages for automobiles, homes, businesses, and personal belongings. They provide peace of mind and protection in case of disaster, tailored insurance programs to meet specific needs, and exceptional customer service.


2. Richfield State Insurance

Richfield State Insurance is an independent insurance agency that provides personal and business insurance products. They offer coverage for automobiles, homes, boats, recreational vehicles, and life insurance.


3. Mark Pietia - North Star Insurance

North Star Insurance Services is an insurance agency based in Minnesota, Michigan, Illinois, and Wisconsin that provides auto, home, and life insurance.


4. Reliable Insurance Network, Inc

Reliable Insurance Network is an independent, full-service agency specializing in providing insurance coverage to clients in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Arizona. They work with top-rated national insurance companies to offer customized packages to fit the unique needs of their clients, including auto, homeowner's, business, and life insurance.


5. State Farm Insurance Agency

Bruce Knows Insurance is a company dedicated to helping people manage everyday life risks, recover from unexpected events, and achieve their dreams.


6. Soderholm Insurance Services

Soderholm Insurance Services is a premier local insurance agency in Minnesota, dedicated to serving the diverse insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses. We provide exceptional insurance solutions to protect your biggest assets at competitive rates, offering coverage options for personal insurance, business insurance, and specialty insurance. With our superior knowledge and expertise, we help secure the most effective insurance plans tailored to Minnesota's state laws and regulations. Join our family and experience the peace of mind you've been searching for.


7. Stein Insurance Agency Inc

Stein Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Lindstrom, Minnesota. They offer a wide range of insurance products including auto, home, life, commercial, and recreational vehicle insurance. With a focus on personal attention and building strong customer relationships, they provide custom insurance programs tailored to meet individual and business needs.


8. Lakeside Insurance Brokers

Lakeside Insurance Brokers is an independent insurance agency based in Minnesota. With over 25 years of experience, we offer guidance and help clients make the right decisions for their home, auto, and business insurance needs. Our experienced agents provide personalized service and find affordable and comprehensive coverage options from a wide range of reliable insurance companies. We prioritize customer satisfaction and take care of our clients like family.


9. Insurance Warehouse LLC

Insurance Warehouse is a professional, experienced, and reliable insurance company based in Minneapolis, MN. They offer a wide range of insurance policies, including home, auto, boat, health, life, motorcycle, renters, RV, and umbrella insurance. Their team of knowledgeable professionals provides personalized service and works with over 30 highly rated insurance companies to find the best coverage and rates for their customers.


10. Freedom Insurance Agency

Freedom Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Burnsville, Minnesota, providing affordable and complete insurance options for individual, family, and business insurance needs.


11. Realogy Insurance Agency

Realogy Insurance is one of America’s leading providers of personal lines insurance, offering a wide range of insurance coverages including homeowners, renters, auto, valuable articles, umbrella liability, and more. They provide quotes from multiple national and regional companies, giving customers the convenience of shopping from trusted names in the industry.


12. McNamara Company

McNamara Company provides comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Minnesota. With over fifty years of experience, we offer home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, and more. Our dedicated team takes the time to understand your needs and matches you with the proper coverage at competitive prices.


13. Farmers Union Agency

Farmers Union Agency Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Minnesota. They offer a range of insurance services including home, auto, business, life, farm, crop, and health insurance. They work with multiple insurance companies to find the best coverage at competitive rates.


14. Princeton Agencies, Inc

Princeton Insurance Agency is one of the largest family-owned insurance agencies in Minnesota, offering professional and dependable insurance services to over 11,000 personal and business clients. With direct contracts with more than 40 insurance carriers, they strive to find the best solution for their clients' insurance needs.


15. Holt Insurance Agency

Holt offers plans from reputable insurance carriers that will protect you and not break the bank. We don't just work with any insurance carrier. What we offer our customers, we use ourselves. Over the past 70 years we have taken the time to partner with those we feel best suit our client base. Donegal, Safeco, Allied, MetLife, Travelers, and Auto Owners are all reputable carriers with a proven history of providing sound insurance solutions for customers. We have been insured by these carriers for decades - and know exactly what they can do to protect you.


16. Insurance Brokers of MN

  • Website: jenseninsure.com
  • Headquarters: Blaine, Minnesota, United States
  • Headcount: 51-200

Jensen Agency is an insurance brokerage firm based in Minnesota that offers personal and commercial insurance policies. They provide coverage for auto, homeowners, boat, recreational vehicles, renters, and more.


17. John W Traeger Agency Inc

John W. Traeger Insurance Agency offers a wide range of personal and business insurance solutions, including auto, home, health, life, and recreational vehicle insurance. Their dedicated team of experienced agents works one-on-one with clients to find the right coverage to suit their needs.


18. Town & Country Agency

  • Website: tcamn.com
  • Headquarters: Russell, Minnesota, United States
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Town and Country Agency is an independent insurance agency serving Minnesota residents since 1977. They are a service-oriented entity that represents many fine insurance companies for which they sell insurance policies, providing protection against the possibility of loss at the most reasonable prices.


19. Central Lakes Insurance Brokers

Central Lakes Insurance Brokers is a locally-owned and operated insurance company with offices in Edina and Brainerd, Minnesota. They offer quality insurance products for individuals and businesses, including auto, home, commercial, boat, life, health, recreational, renters, umbrella, brewery, food truck, and property manager insurance.


20. State Insurance

Our Commitment Starts with a Policy… and Continues with a Relationship. Some insurance agents may care more about making a sale than actually providing a policy that properly protects their clients. Our team of experienced insurance professionals is dedicated to working on a personal level with each and every single one of our customers, and that’s what makes us different. We think it’s important to understand your family’s or your business’ unique situation, and then create an insurance policy that is truly the best fit. We hope to build a relationship with you over time. As your life changes or your business evolves over time, our relationship will be key in allowing us to continue to offer you the best protection.


21. Synergy Insurance Group

Synergy Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency offering a wide range of insurance solutions for personal and business needs. They work with renowned insurance companies like Nationwide and Progressive to ensure the best coverage for their clients.


22. Lake Country Insurance Services LLC

Lake Country Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency offering personalized insurance coverage for home, auto, business and life in Minnesota.


Want to find more auto insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer varied services from car, home, to life insurance you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!