The health insurance industry in Indiana consists of companies providing diverse health plans and resources for individuals. The focus is on offering medical coverage, wellness schemes, health management tools, recovery aids, access to trusted healthcare providers, and disease-specific programs. In the wake of the global health crisis, many have adapted to provide essential COVID-19 resources and coverage. As healthcare needs, technologies, and regulations evolve, these companies strive to match pace by innovating their offerings and improving service deliveries.


Top 22 individual health insurance companies in Indiana

1. Anthem

  • Website: anthem.com
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Headcount: 10001+
  • LinkedIn

Anthem.com provides healthcare and insurance services to individuals and organizations. They offer a range of resources and tools to help individuals manage their health and recovery, including behavioral health support and addiction recovery. With their mobile app, users can access benefits, submit documents, and receive renewal reminders. Anthem also provides disease management programs for conditions such as asthma, diabetes, and heart disease.


2. MDwise, Inc.

  • Website: mdwise.org
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1994
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

MDwise is a health insurance company that offers a range of health benefits to its members. They provide services such as medical coverage, wellness programs, and access to a network of healthcare providers.


3. Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana (PHP)

  • Website: phpni.com
  • Headquarters: Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1983
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

PHP is a health insurance company that offers coverage, testing information, and vaccination resources for COVID-19. They provide health plans for large and small employer groups, coverage for prescriptions and pharmacy needs, and various health and wellness programs. PHP aims to provide great benefits while conserving cash flow for their customers.


4. Brewer Financial Group

Jane Brewer Insurance Services, also known as Brewer Financial Group, is a family-owned insurance company founded in 1996. They provide health insurance to individuals and families as well as employee benefits to small and large groups from various top-rated insurance carriers.


5. New Edge Solutions

  • Website: gonewedge.com
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 2020
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

New Edge Solutions is a specialized benefits agency offering healthcare solutions that provide consistent savings, immediate and long-term healthcare savings, and a superior employer and employee experience. Their services include Individual Coverage HRA and Level Funded Health Plans, a Pharmacy Benefit Manager, the Proactive Health Management Plan, and an Indemnity Based Pandemic Protection Program.


6. Jeff Susong - State Farm Insurance Agent

Jeff Susong is an insurance agent in Indianapolis, IN, offering various types of insurance policies such as auto, life, health, home, and business insurance.


7. Amerihealth Inc

AmeriHealth.com is a health plan provider offering extensive network of doctors and hospitals.


8. The DeHayes Group

  • Website: dehayes.com
  • Headquarters: Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1982
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

The DeHayes Group is an independent insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance solutions customized to the needs of businesses and individuals. They offer coverage options for general liability, workers’ compensation, directors and officers liability, employment practices liability, and more. Their team of experienced professionals can help businesses find comprehensive coverage to protect against various risks.


9. Amerigroup Texas Inc

  • Website: amerigroup.com
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1994
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Amerigroup provides low-cost health insurance coverage for children, adults, and families who qualify for state-sponsored programs.


10. Thurston Springer Insurance, LLC

TSI Brokerage offers customized insurance plans and risk management services to protect your financial well-being and goals.


11. Kochert Insurance

Kochert Insurance is an Indiana-based insurance provider that offers auto, home, business, life, and health insurance at affordable prices, catering to individual and group insurance needs.


12. Michael Suhany - State Farm Insurance Agent

Individual Health Insurance Plans, Family Health Insurance Plans, Medicare Plans


13. Employee Benefit Solutions

Employee Benefit Solutions of Indiana Inc, offers a variety of insurance services such as Employee Benefits, Senior Products, Voluntary Benefits, Wellness Consulting, and Long Term Care Products. EBS takes the time to understand what all the balancing factors are in undertaking your HR insurance needs. It is our responsibility to make the best decisions with you for your company. Our bottom line is about proving our worth to your organization over and over again. Too often, insurance benefits are noticed when things go poorly. That simply will never be the case with EBS.


14. Easy Benies LLC

Easy Benies offers employee benefits and personal insurance services to businesses and individuals, with a focus on Hoosier businesses.


15. Conner Insurance

  • Website: connerins.com
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1949
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Conner Insurance provides comprehensive commercial, personal, and benefits insurance solutions coverage for people and businesses in all 50 U.S. states. We become your partner, advisor, and supporter, making the insurance process simple and effective.


16. PMG Insurance Agency

  • Website: pmgagency.com
  • Headquarters: Ft. Wayne, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1999
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

PMG Agency is an independent insurance agency offering competitive and affordable insurance options through multiple insurance companies.


17. Hailey Campbell

Hailey Campbell, Inc. is an independent consulting firm specializing in the healthcare insurance marketplace exchange. They provide a wide range of individual and family health insurance plans along with employee benefit plans for small and large group employers. They also offer life insurance, long term care insurance, and financial products.


18. Elevance Health

  • Website: elevancehealth.com
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1944
  • Headcount: 10001+
  • Latest funding type: Ipo
  • LinkedIn

Elevance Health is a healthcare company that serves people across their entire health journey, offering integrated solutions to address their diverse needs. With a commitment to innovation, Elevance Health focuses on moving health forward. They provide health plans, clinical, behavioral, pharmacy, and complex-care solutions that promote whole health.


19. CNO Financial Group

  • Website: cnoinc.com
  • Headquarters: Carmel, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1979
  • Headcount: 1001-5000
  • Latest funding type: Ipo
  • LinkedIn

CNO Financial Group is a provider of life and health insurance, annuities, financial services, and workforce benefits solutions. Through their family of brands and supported by their associates and agents, they help protect the health, income, and retirement needs of middle-income Americans.


20. American Specialty Health

  • Website: ashcompanies.com
  • Headquarters: Carmel, Indiana, United States
  • Founded: 1987
  • Headcount: 1001-5000
  • Latest funding type: Private Equity
  • LinkedIn

American Specialty Health (ASH) provides health plans, employer groups, insurance carriers, and trust funds with a wide range of health management, fitness and exercise, and musculoskeletal provider networks programs.


21. Unified Group Services

Unified Group Services is a full-service third-party administrator for employee benefit plans. We offer innovative programs and services that make it easy for employees to maximize their benefits. Our commitment to customer satisfaction drives our mission to provide comprehensive and streamlined health benefit solutions.


22. MetLife Pet Insurance

MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC is a provider of pet insurance coverage. They offer policies that help pet owners cover the cost of unexpected visits to the vet for their furry family members. With comprehensive and competitive plans, they provide customizable product offerings starting at $9 a month. Their coverage is available for cats and dogs, and they reimburse a portion of vet bills. They operate under various names in different jurisdictions.


Want to find more individual health insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer a variety of resources, plans, and tailored health coverages you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!