23 Top-Rated Auto Insurance Providers in Indiana
23 Top-Rated Auto Insurance Providers in Indiana
The auto insurance industry in Indiana is highly diversified and competitive, with a myriad of companies offering a broad range of coverage options. From standard automobile insurance to specialized coverage for classic and collector cars, businesses in the sector strive to provide customized plans that meet individual needs. As technological advancements continue to reshape the industry, many providers are leveraging digital platforms to offer flexible and comprehensive services. Further, the future of auto insurance in Indiana may likely see an increased focus on sustainable practices and enhanced customer experiences.
Top 23 auto insurance companies in Indiana
1. Indiana Farmers Insurance
- Website: indianafarmers.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1877
- Headcount: 201-500
Indiana Farmers is an insurance company that offers auto, home, and farm insurance coverage. They customize plans to meet the needs of their customers, providing affordable rates and expert guidance. With over 140 years of experience, Indiana Farmers is committed to protecting their customers' investments and helping them manage risks.
2. The Thompson Group
- Website: thethompsongroup.net
- Headquarters: Parker City, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1996
- Headcount: 11-50
The Thompson Group is a risk management company that offers a wide range of insurance services, including personal insurance, homeowner's insurance, auto insurance, agriculture insurance, and employee insurance. They provide expert guidance in uncovering exposures to risk and offer tailored insurance solutions to protect individuals and businesses.
3. Classic Auto Insurance Agency, Inc
- Website: classicins.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1992
- Headcount: 11-50
Classicins.com is an insurance company specialized in providing classic car and collector car insurance coverage. They offer tailored insurance plans to protect and preserve the legacy of their clients' valuable car collections.
4. Crowel Agency Inc
- Website: crowelinsurance.com
- Headquarters: Highland, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1965
- Headcount: 11-50
Crowel Insurance offers various insurance policies, including auto insurance and homeowners insurance, to protect individuals, their vehicles, and their homes from damages and accidents. They provide reliable coverage and assistance in case of incidents, ensuring peace of mind for their customers.
5. Pfenninger, Claxton & Estelle Insurance Agency
- Website: pceinsure.com
- Headquarters: New Castle, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1902
- Headcount: 11-50
PCE Insure is an insurance agency committed to understanding and proactively addressing customers' risk management and insurance needs. They offer a variety of personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, home, life, renters, and cyber liability insurance. With a focus on client-centered service, they provide 24/7 access to agents and guide customers through the claims process for prompt resolution.
6. Steffey Insurance Agency
- Website: steffeyins.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1982
- Headcount: 11-50
Steffey Insurance is a full-service insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance options including auto, homeowners, business, life, and health insurance. They offer personalized solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of each client, whether an individual or a business. With over 40 years of experience, they are committed to providing excellent service and finding the right insurance coverage at competitive prices.
7. Springer Insurance
- Website: springerinsurance.com
- Headquarters: Sullivan, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1987
- Headcount: 11-50
Springer Insurance is an insurance agency offering a variety of insurance products to protect individuals, businesses, and farmers against potential losses. Their offerings include home insurance, auto insurance, commercial insurance, crop insurance, health and life insurance, and farm insurance.
8. Conner Insurance
- Website: connerins.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1949
- Headcount: 11-50
Conner Insurance provides comprehensive commercial, personal, and benefits insurance solutions coverage for people and businesses in all 50 U.S. states. We become your partner, advisor, and supporter, making the insurance process simple and effective.
9. Goshert Insurance LLC
- Website: goshertins.com
- Headquarters: Warsaw, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 2002
- Headcount: 11-50
Goshert Insurance LLC is an independent insurance agency based in Warsaw, Indiana. They offer a wide range of insurance coverages including auto, home, business, and agriculture. With a dedicated team of experts, they provide personalized and cost-effective insurance solutions to their clients.
10. United Insurance Agencies
- Website: uiaweb.com
- Headquarters: Muncie, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1918
- Headcount: 11-50
uiaweb.com offers affordable insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. They provide a wide range of coverage options and strive to find the lowest prices to fit the unique needs of each customer. With a dedicated staff known for friendly service, they make the insurance process easy and aim to save customers money.
11. Rahvy R. Murray Ins Agency Inc. StateFarm
- Website: murraysfinsurance.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Headcount: 201-500
Our goal is to assist individuals and families in insuring that they receive the benefits of all their hard work. We are committed to providing a personalized approach to your insurance needs, always with integrity and a passion to help you and your family get to the future.
12. Wetzel Insurance Agency
- Website: wetzel1.com
- Headquarters: Warsaw, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1928
- Headcount: 11-50
Wetzel Insurance Agency is a leading insurance agency in Indiana, providing quality insurance services since 1928. We work with reputable insurance companies and employ dedicated insurance professionals. Our commitment is to offer the best insurance coverage and maintain long-term relationships with our clients.
13. Callistus Smith Agency
- Website: callistussmith.com
- Headquarters: Floyds Knobs, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1947
- Headcount: 11-50
Callistus Smith Agency is a local, family-owned insurance agency that has been protecting families and businesses since 1947. We offer honest, transparent, and personalized insurance plans to our customers. With a focus on providing the highest quality coverage at affordable rates, we treat our customers like family, not just transactions.
14. Healy Group
- Website: healygroup.com
- Headquarters: South Bend, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1976
- Headcount: 11-50
The Healy Group is an insurance company that offers comprehensive coverage and competitive rates. They prioritize customer satisfaction and aim to provide worry-free insurance services.
15. Tribbett Rich Insurance
- Website: insurewithtrig.com
- Headquarters: Lebanon, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 2014
- Headcount: 201-500
Tribbett Rich Insurance Group is to provide the highest quality insurance and service at the best possible prices to their clients.
16. CarrierHQ
- Website: carrierhq.com
- Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 2017
- Headcount: 11-50
CarrierHQ is a company that provides innovative technology solutions for the transportation industry. They offer a wide range of services including fleet management, compliance support, and logistics optimization.
17. Peck And Wood Insurance
- Website: peckandwoodinsurance.com
- Headquarters: Anderson, Indiana, United States
- Headcount: 11-50
Peck and Wood Insurance is an independent insurance agency providing insurance solutions for auto, home, life, business, and farm. They offer a variety of policies tailored to the needs of their clients, including group health benefits for businesses.
18. Hayes Murphy Sharp & Brackney Ins
- Website: hmsbins.com
- Headquarters: Greencastle, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 2004
- Headcount: 11-50
Brackney Insurance provides personalized insurance programs to suit each client's needs at affordable prices. They have a wide range of services, including auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, and commercial insurance.
19. Leadership Insurance Agency Inc
- Website: leadershipins.com
- Headquarters: South Bend, Indiana, United States
- Headcount: 11-50
Leadership Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance agency providing home, auto, life, and health insurance. With over 100 years of combined insurance experience, professional agents offer individual attention and the best coverage at the lowest possible price in the greater South Bend, Mishawaka, and Elkhart areas.
20. Heston Insurance
- Website: heston-insurance.com
- Headquarters: Evansville, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1933
- Headcount: 11-50
Heston Insurance Agency provides insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, offering a range of products such as auto, home, health, life, recreational vehicle, and commercial insurance.
21. Mettler Agency Inc
- Website: mettleragency.com
- Headquarters: Huntington, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 1950
- Headcount: 11-50
Mettler Agency Inc. provides personal, business, vehicle, and health insurance coverage options to meet the insurance needs of individuals and businesses in Huntington, IN and nearby areas.
22. Grove Insurance Agency
- Website: groveins.com
- Headquarters: Brownsburg, Indiana, United States
- Founded: 2005
- Headcount: 11-50
Grove Insurance Agency is an insurance provider catering to clients in Indiana, Michigan, Texas, Nevada, Georgia, South Carolina, Florida, Alabama, Ohio, Mississippi, North Carolina, Kentucky, and Illinois. They offer car, home, life, flood, boat/watercraft, classic car, condo, motorcycle, renters, RV, and umbrella insurance policies.
23. Lon Brown Insurance
- Website: lonbrownins.com
- Headquarters: Alexandria, Indiana, United States
- Headcount: 11-50
Brown Insurance Group has been offering insurance products for over 70 years to tens of thousands of customers in various states. They provide peace of mind in safeguarding financial dreams against possible setbacks and strive to offer “Good Old Fashioned Service”.
Want to find more auto insurance companies?
If you want to find more companies that offer diverse coverage options customized to the policyholder's needs you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.
With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:
- Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
- Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
- Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?
...and a lot more!
