The auto insurance industry in Vermont is diverse and dynamic. It is made up of various companies that offer a range of services to cater to the distinctive needs of motorists. They provide protection against financial loss and liability resulting from accidents, reaching from comprehensive and collision coverage to personal injury protection and liability insurance. The sector also offers benefits such as roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and insurance bundling. The future of the industry rests on leveraging digital innovations to offer streamlined experiences, personalized coverages, and improved customer service.


Top 23 auto insurance companies in Vermont

1. Polly

  • Website: polly.co
  • Headquarters: Williston, Vermont, United States
  • Founded: 2012
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Series C
  • LinkedIn

Polly.co is an insurance agency that specializes in helping car buyers manage their car insurance coverage. They offer a seamless experience by embedding car insurance from trusted carriers, making car buying faster, easier, and more valuable. With Polly, customers can compare quotes, get instant proof of coverage, and save money by bundling their car insurance with other personal assets. They provide exceptional customer service and personalized advice from award-winning agent advisors.


2. DealerPolicy

DealerPolicy is an insurance agency that specializes in providing insurance solutions for automotive retailers. They offer a fully digital dealership experience, allowing retailers to bring their team, tools, and data together to launch high-impact inbound marketing campaigns in less time. With their comprehensive insurance sales careers and carrier partnerships, DealerPolicy helps retailers grow their business like a team twice their size.


3. 123 Insurance, INC.

123 Insurance offers customized insurance packages for individuals and businesses in Vermont. Their products range from auto, home, farm, to business insurance. The company is committed to finding the best price and coverage for their customers.


4. Kinney Pike Insurance, A OneDigital Company

Kinney Pike is an insurance company that offers a wide range of insurance products for businesses and individuals. They work with trusted providers to provide quality service and advocacy for their clients. In addition to insurance, they also offer risk management and safety services to help businesses mitigate potential risks.


5. Ludlow Ins Agency

Ludlow Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that offers a variety of insurance solutions, including home, auto, recreational vehicle, life, business, and more. They have been in operation for over 84 years and represent 10 stable insurance companies.


6. Kaitlyn Raymond - State Farm Insurance Agent

Raymond Insurance Agency Inc is an independent insurance agent located in Essex, Vermont. They offer a variety of insurance products and services such as auto, home, renters, business, life, and pet insurance. Their top priority is taking care of their customers and ensuring their satisfaction.


7. Hull Maynard Hersey Insurance Services, Inc.

  • Website: hmhvt.com
  • Headquarters: Rutland, Vermont, United States
  • Founded: 1978
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Hull Maynard Hersey Insurance is a Vermont-based insurance agency providing auto, home, business, workers compensation, motorcycle, umbrella, life, boat, and snowmobile insurance.


8. Richard Jones - State Farm Insurance Agent

Rich Jones State Farm Insurance office serves Montpelier, VT offering a range of insurances like Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Life, and Commercial, focused on resident relocations to Washington County area with a personal touch.


9. Crowley Insurance Agency

Crowley Insurance Agency offers personal and commercial insurance coverages to individuals, families, and business owners, helping customers find the perfect balance of cost and coverage.


10. Taylor-moore Agency, INC.

Taylor-Moore Agency provides commercial and business insurance for various industries which include general liability, automobile, contractor liability, and bonding insurance. Caters to electricians, gutter installation, landscapers, septic installation, excavators, masons, and other general contractors.


11. North Country Insurance

North Country Insurance can accomadate any personal or commercial needs, covering you at home, work, or play. We strive to provide the customer with the best available rates, to administer our clients with unparalleled customer service, and to resolve problems before they occur.


12. Cruz Insurance Agency Inc

Cruz Insurance Agency works with several insurance underwriters to provide auto, motorcycle, watercraft, and RV insurance at an affordable price to meet individual needs. The agency helps customers find the right policy to save them money.


13. Wyman Agency

The Wyman Agency is a locally owned and family operated insurance agency. Our knowledgeable staff and professional service is available to anyone with personal or commercial insurance needs. We are licensed to help connect clients throughout Vermont and New Hampshire with affordable coverage tailored to fit individual needs. We offer a wide range of insurance services, including but not limited to home and auto, recreational vehicle, farms, business liability and property, business auto, life, disability and annuities. We welcome you to give us a call or stop by for free consultation. We look forward to meeting you.


14. Cruz Insurance Agency

Cruz Insurance Agency, Inc. is committed to our client's complete satisfaction. We are an Award Winning Agency, offering you 24 Hour a Day Service! The types of insurances products we offer include: Auto, Antique Auto, Commercial Auto, Home, Renters, Umbrella, Condo, Boat, Flood, Snowmobile, Motorcycle, Life, Annuities, Disability & Long Term Care Insurance Products, Commercial, Contractors, and Workers Comp.


15. Barsalow Insurance Agency

The Barsalow Insurance Agency is committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance plans available combined with some of the lowest rates available in all of Vermont. Whether you're shopping for auto insurance, home insurance, health, life or business insurance, we can help get you the best coverage available with the lowest rate possible. At Barsalow Insurance Agency, our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for many years to come. We specialize in the following Vermont Insurance Services: Auto Insurance Home Insurance Health Insurance Life Insurance Business Insurance And Much, Much More! Although we are located in Milton, Vermont, we offer unparalleled service and competitive quotes to clients throughout the entire State of Vermont!


16. Fewer Agency

  • Website: feweragency.com
  • Headquarters: Barre, Vermont, United States
  • Headcount: 1-10

The Fewer Agency covering all of your personal and business needs. Our convenient website allows you to request insurance quotes twenty-four hours a day. Our valued customers can also service their policies at anytime, day or night, at feweragency.com.


17. Durkee Agency

Durkee Agency is an independent insurance agency that provides personal, commercial, life, and health insurance.


18. Woodstock Insurance, INC.

At Woodstock Insurance, INC., we are committed to protecting your privacy as a visitor to this Web site and as our customer. To our visitors and to our customers, we offer this pledge: Woodstock Insurance, Inc. is the owner of the information, which is collected on this Web site. We will not sell, disseminate, disclose, trade, transmit, transfer, share, lease or rent any personally identifiable information to any third party not specifically authorized by you to receive your information except as we have disclosed to you in this Privacy Policy.


19. Cheeseman Insurance Group

Cheeseman Insurance Group is a company that operates in the Insurance industry. It employs 6-10 people and has $1M-$5M of revenue. The company is headquartered in Burlington, Vermont.


20. Pleasant Valley Insurance

Pleasant Valley Insurance is an Independent Insurance Agency representing many different insurance companies for your insurance needs. We carefully select our carriers in order to provide you with the best level of service, price and coverage. As independent insurance agents, you have the ability to choose the best carrier for your insurance needs. That is the main advantage to using an independent insurance agency, we work to satisfy your needs. Located in Jeffersonville, Vermont our goal is to educate and service the Lamoille County community and throughout the state of Vermont. Through our independence, we strive to educate the community on the best options for their insurance needs. We can provide an assessment of your insurance needs with a choice of which package fits you best. We are dedicated to providing our customers in Vermont with the best coverage at competitive rates. Just make one call to our agency, and we can shop your coverage through many top rated companies. With our professional staff, we can be your liaison with the insurance carrier in the event of a claim. We work for you, not the insurance company. We want you to have a positive overall experience with Pleasant Valley Insurance. Our one on one service approach is our #1 goal for all our insurance clients. Give us a call at 802-644-9900 or contact us through one of our quote forms, and we'll be happy to answer any of your insurance questions.


21. Ken Nelson Agency

Personal lines insurance


22. Jamieson

Jamieson Insurance offers home, auto and business insurance services.


23. Turnbaugh Insurance Agency

Turnbaugh Insurance Agency provides affordable and reliable insurance choices in Vermont. They offer tailored insurance coverage for individuals and businesses, including home, life, car, and contractor insurance.


Want to find more auto insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer comprehensive, tailored products and progressive customer service you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!