Dwelling in the arena of risk management, home insurance companies provide a sense of financial security to homeowners in the face of unpredictable circumstances. From natural disasters, fire mishaps to thefts, these entities cater to an extensive array of housing issues providing all-inclusive coverage. The home insurance industry is in a perpetual state of evolution, constantly amending its policies to align with the changing societal needs and expectations, thereby progressing towards a more inclusive and comprehensive insurance model. The booming real estate market in New York, with its high property value, fuels the necessity for reliable home insurers ensuring maximum protection.


Top 23 home insurance companies in New York

1. Policygenius Inc.

  • Website: policygenius.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2014
  • Headcount: 501-1000
  • Latest funding type: Series E
  • LinkedIn

Policygenius is a platform that allows customers to compare and purchase various insurance products including life, home, auto, disability, and renters insurance. They provide free quotes and policy information from leading insurance companies, helping customers find the best coverage at the best price.


2. CoverWallet, an Aon company

  • Website: coverwallet.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2015
  • Headcount: 501-1000
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

CoverWallet is an online platform that helps small businesses protect and manage their insurance needs. They offer a variety of insurance policies for different industries, including general liability, property, professional liability, and workers compensation.


3. Seneca Insurance Company

Seneca Insurance is a company that provides insurance services to individuals and businesses. They offer a range of insurance products, including auto, home, business, and life insurance. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Seneca Insurance strives to provide reliable coverage and personalized solutions to meet their clients' needs.


4. Merchants Insurance Group

Merchants Insurance Group provides property and casualty insurance protection to policyholders since 1918. They offer a range of insurance products for businesses and individuals, including auto, home, business, and personal umbrella insurance. The company prides itself on quality customer service and flexible payment options. They also have a strong presence in the retail and wholesale sectors, serving businesses like restaurants, bakeries, coffee shops, delis, and more.


5. Brownstone Agency, Inc.

Brownstone Agency is an insurance company that has been providing quality and affordable insurance coverage throughout the residential real estate industry since 1973.


6. Kingstone Insurance Company

Kingstone Insurance offers coverage for homeowners, landlords, and personal umbrella policies in NY, CT, and NJ. They provide tailored coverages to meet individual needs and prioritize customer satisfaction. They also offer canin legal liability policies and coverage for physical damage for hire. Kingstone Insurance aims to protect investments and ensure policy choices that make sense for their customers.


7. AmTrust RE

  • Website: amtrustre.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1993
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

AmTrustRE is a company that specializes in providing insurance coverage for real estate properties. They offer a range of policies to protect property owners from financial losses due to damages or liability claims. With a focus on customer service and risk management, AmTrustRE aims to provide comprehensive coverage solutions for the real estate industry.


8. Attune

  • Website: attuneinsurance.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2017
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Attune Insurance is a user-friendly platform that offers customized coverage for small businesses in minutes. It provides a wide range of insurance products, including business interruption coverage, flood insurance, cyber insurance, workers' compensation, and general liability. Attune's online portal allows for easy management of clients' policies and offers immediate notifications about payment confirmation and policy status. The company aims to streamline the commercial insurance process through efficient underwriting, paperless transactions, and competitive commission rates.


9. Colstan & Associates Inc.

  • Website: colstan.com
  • Headquarters: West Babylon, New York, United States
  • Founded: 2000
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Colstan & Associates Inc. is an insurance agency that offers a wide variety of business and personal insurance solutions. With over two decades of experience, they strive to provide top quality coverage at affordable rates. Their services include auto insurance, homeowners insurance, commercial property insurance, and more.


10. Hudson United Mortgage

Hudson United offers mortgage, title, and insurance services all working together. They provide a simplified mortgage experience with a lending team that has successfully closed thousands of local real estate transactions. They also offer insurance policies and fast title work for hassle-free homeowner's policies and fast closings.


11. Global Coverage, Inc.

Global Coverage, Inc. provides comprehensive insurance products for a diverse clientele across the country.


12. Weg & Myers

Weg and Myers, P.C. is an insurance law firm specializing in first party property insurance coverage and third-party insurance coverage. They handle cases related to property damage, litigation, and public adjusters. With a team of experienced attorneys, they provide legal representation and counsel to clients facing insurance disputes, helping them navigate complex insurance policies and obtain fair settlements. Their website offers valuable information about their practice areas, verdicts, and the team members.


13. Infinity Auto Insurance

  • Website: infinityauto.com
  • Headquarters: Syracuse, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1955
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Infinity Auto is a company that offers a range of insurance products, including vehicle insurance, commercial insurance, property insurance, and other insurance options. They provide policies that protect individuals and businesses from various risks, with competitive prices and convenient online purchasing options.


14. New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association

  • Website: nypiua.com
  • Headquarters: New York, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1968
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

NYPIUA is the New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association, providing insurance solutions in New York. They specialize in insurance coverage for dwelling fire, commercial property, and more. Contact them for assistance with policy management, making payments, reporting claims, and general information.


15. Bailey Place Insurance

Bailey Place is an insurance company that offers a wide range of policies to meet the needs of individuals and businesses. They provide exceptional customer service and strive to find the best coverage at affordable rates. Whether it's home, auto, or business insurance, Bailey Place is dedicated to protecting what matters most.


16. Borrelli Partners Insurance Agency, LLC

Borrelli Partners Insurance Agency is a leading provider in insurance and services in the insurance industry. They pride themselves on providing the best customer experience possible while also offering affordable insurance rates. With relationships with dozens of insurance companies, they ensure their customers get the right price with the right service.


17. Elmwood Agency

The Elmwood Agency is an independent insurance agency that offers a diverse selection of coverage lines and expert support from a team of dedicated agents. They go beyond selling homeowners policies and assist customers in finding realtors and mortgage applications. With headquarters in Rochester NY, they strive to make insurance shopping more rewarding and affordable.


18. Industrial Coverage

Industrial Coverage is an independent insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance solutions for both commercial and personal needs. With a dedicated team of experienced agents, they offer comprehensive coverage backed by the best insurers in the industry.


19. Millennium Alliance Group, LLC

  • Website: mag-insurance.com
  • Headquarters: Melville, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1998
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Mag Insurance is an independent insurance agency that specializes in providing contractor equipment insurance and general liability insurance to contractors. They offer coverage for tools and equipment, as well as protection against property damage and third-party claims. With a focus on personalized service and tailored insurance solutions, Mag Insurance ensures that contractors have the necessary coverage to protect their business.


20. Scalzo, Zogby & Wittig, Inc. Insurance Agency

SZW Insurance is an independent insurance agency that offers a wide range of insurance products and services. They provide coverage for vehicles, property, businesses, and individuals. With a team of experienced professionals, they can help customers find the right insurance solutions tailored to their specific needs.


21. I Dachs & Sons Inc

Dachs Insurance is a commercial and personal insurance broker that has been serving the community since 1895. They offer a comprehensive range of innovative insurance products to a diverse range of clients across the country.


22. Aegis Service Corp

Aegis Service Corp offers insurance products for personal automobile, homeowners, renters, recreational vehicle, and other property and liability needs. They provide efficient and reliable services with a team of experienced insurance professionals. Customers can expect personalized attention and quick response to their insurance needs.


23. Mackoul Risk Solutions

  • Website: mackoul.com
  • Headquarters: Island Park, New York, United States
  • Founded: 1987
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Mackoul Risk Solutions is a commercial insurance company providing condominium and co-op insurance in Long Island, NY. They offer personalized insurance solutions to protect businesses and individuals.


Want to find more home insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer comprehensive coverage addressing a myriad of housing concerns you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!