Solutions

arrow down
Private EquityInvestment BankingBusiness BrokersConsultingCorporate Development
Our Data

Company

arrow down
About UsCareer

Resources

arrow down
ArticlesDownloadsCase Studier
Resources
inven

Top 23 Wisconsin Home Insurance Providers

4
min read
Top 23 home insurance companies in Wisconsin Main

Top 23 Wisconsin Home Insurance Providers

4
min read
Get started
Top 23 home insurance companies in Wisconsin Main
Top firms trust Inven to find niche companies

The home insurance industry in Wisconsin consists of large corporations, local firms, and everything in-between offering an array of coverage options. These companies offer comprehensive protection for residences against damages related to incidents like fire, theft, and natural disasters. In addition to basic coverage, many companies provide additional services like liability protection, which covers legal expenses in case individuals file lawsuits for injuries incurred on premises. In the era of growing climate risks, the industry is seeing a trend towards policies covering damages caused by climate change-related events such as floods and wildfires. These insurance companies also offer personalized solutions to cater to different needs.


Top 23 home insurance companies in Wisconsin

1. R&R Insurance Services Inc.

My Knowledge Broker is a company that offers various types of insurance and financial services. They provide personal and business insurance policies, including home, auto, flood, and cyber insurance. Additionally, they offer services related to health insurance, employee benefits, and risk management. With a focus on protecting individuals and businesses from potential risks and providing reliable coverage, My Knowledge Broker is a trusted partner in insurance and financial services.


2. Badger Mutual Insurance Company

Badger Mutual is an insurance company that offers personal and commercial insurance policies. They specialize in protecting individuals and businesses by providing tailored coverage options for their properties, vehicles, and liability. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Badger Mutual has been in the insurance industry since 1887 and continues to prioritize the needs of their clients.


3. JM Insurance Services, LLC

JM Insurance Services is a full-service insurance agency that offers customized protection for personal and business insurance needs. They are an affiliate agency of Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company, providing expert advisors to find optimal coverage for each type of insurance, including home, car, and business insurance. Customers have praised their attentive and helpful service, saving them significant premiums compared to other quotes.


4. Mutual of Wausau Insurance Corp.

Mutual of Wausau is an insurance corporation that offers a wide range of products to protect the homes, farms, and businesses of its policyholders. They prioritize the mutual interests of their customers and aim to provide a better insurance experience.


5. Procter Insurance Agency

Procter Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in South Milwaukee, Wisconsin. With a goal to assist customers in all their insurance needs, they offer a variety of insurance products to choose from. Their dedicated staff works on the customers' side to ensure fair and prompt payment and service. Procter Insurance represents a selected group of reputable insurance companies, providing customers with the best coverage at competitive prices.


6. Germantown Mutual Insurance Company

  • Website: gmic.com
  • Headquarters: Germantown, Wisconsin, United States
  • Founded: 1854
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

GMIC is an insurance company that offers property and casualty insurance services in Wisconsin and Utah. With over 169 years of experience, GMIC is a trusted provider, rated A (Excellent) by AM Best since 1922. They offer an online claims service for easy submissions and provide 24/7 claims support.


7. McMillan Warner Mutual Insurance Company

McMillan Warner Mutual Insurance is a local mutual insurance company that specializes in providing home, farm, and other insurance services. With a focus on service and stability, they offer a range of insurance products and have a history of serving their community. They are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and maintaining strong relationships with their policyholders and agents.


8. Abel Insurance

  • Website: abelins.com
  • Headquarters: Kaukauna, Wisconsin, United States
  • Founded: 1967
  • Headcount: 1-10
  • LinkedIn

Abel Insurance is an independent insurance agent providing affordable, thorough coverage and prompt service from a wide choice of plans and programs available. They offer personal and business insurance coverage services.


9. Main Street Insurance Agency

Main Street Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Ashland, Wisconsin. They offer insurance for home, car, small business, and other property. They help customers shop and compare coverage from various insurance companies to find the right policy that matches their unique needs and budget.


10. RetireCo

  • Website: retireco.com
  • Headquarters: Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States
  • Founded: 2009
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn

RetireCo is a company offering a wide range of insurance and financial products to individuals and businesses. They provide access to over 500 top-rated carriers across both life + health and property + casualty lines, ensuring clients are never limited in their options. With over 17,000 products from hundreds of carriers, RetireCo aims to tailor custom solutions for clients' needs.


11. Leonard Insurance

Leonard Insurance Services is an insurance agency that provides personalized and caring attention to their clients. They offer a variety of insurance options and strive to find the best rates for their customers.


12. The Trottier Insurance Group

The Trottier Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency located in Kenosha Wisconsin. Trottier is committed to creating both professional and personal relationships with their clients with Auto, Home, Life/Health and Business Insurance. Trottier has been a leader in local Kenosha Insurance sales since 1963.


13. Fuhrman Insurance Unlimited Inc

Fuhrman Insurance Agency Unlimited Inc. is an independent insurance agency providing various insurance coverages including Auto, Home, Farm, Life, Annuity, Watercraft, Snowmobile, Business Income, Life and Health Benefits, Property, Mobile Home, Inland Marine, ATV/Recreation Vehicles, Workers Compensation, and Medicare supplement insurance throughout Wisconsin and Arizona.


14. St Croix Valley Insurance Svc

St. Croix Valley Insurance specializes in providing insurance products to businesses and individuals. Their services include areas such as commercial property insurance, cybersecurity insurance, business liability insurance, classic car insurance, and workers compensation insurance.


15. Republic Associates of WI

  • Website: rep-ins.com
  • Headquarters: Elm Grove, Wisconsin, United States
  • Founded: 1984
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Republic Associates of WI is an independent insurance agent providing insurance policies for personal and business needs. They offer a variety of insurance services such as auto, home, life, and health insurance backed by experienced staff and prompt, accurate, and courteous client service.


16. Jacobson Insurance Services LLC

Jacobson Insurance Services LLC is an independent insurance agency offering personal, business, and life insurance needs in northeast Wisconsin. They represent financially strong, reputable insurance companies, to offer the best coverage at the most competitive price.


17. Coulee Region Insurance & Financial

Coulee Region Insurance & Financial, Inc. provides insurance solutions for personal and business needs. They work with a variety of top carriers to help customers find the best coverage that suits their unique situation


18. R&S Insurance Agency

  • Website: rs-ins.com
  • Headquarters: Stoughton, Wisconsin, United States
  • Founded: 1964
  • Headcount: 1-10
  • LinkedIn

This is an insurance agency that provides personal and commercial insurance solutions. They offer a variety of insurance services including health, auto, home, workers comp, and liability. Customers can easily obtain an insurance quote by filling out a form or uploading their current policy information.


19. Alongi Santas Moss Insurance Agency

Alongi Santas Moss Insurance Agency is a firm that gives small town treatment with big agency service. We have proven professionals who are caring and conscientious people the kind of people you can depend on. We have made a commitment to provide our clients with insurance solutions through value added service, which not only exceeds our customers' expectations, but distinctly sets us apart from our peers. We strive to maintain a high standard of excellence in all that we do and to estabilishing a firm relationship of mutual trust and service to each of our clients. Alongi Santas Moss Insurance Agency has served the Stateline area for over 50 years as an independent insurance agency. This means we work for our clients with a multiple number of insurance companies. When you have a loss, we help you through the process every step of the way to assure fair treatment and prompt payment. We represent a carefully selected group of insurance companies that are financially sound--companies that have proven year after year to give quality service for a competitive price. This allows us here at Alongi Santas Moss the ability to advice and grow with you as our valued client.


20. Richards Insurance Agency

Richards Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agent offering expert insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, with a focus on farm/agribusiness, auto, home, life, and business insurance in Wisconsin.


21. Compass Insurance Group, Inc.

Compass Insurance Group is an independent agency offering comprehensive insurance solutions in Wisconsin and Illinois for personal and business needs.


22. Town &a; Country Insurance

  • Website: tcins1.com
  • Headquarters: Blanchardville, Wisconsin, United States
  • Headcount: 11-50

Town & Country Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency that offers a comprehensive range of insurance products to meet the needs of individuals, families, and businesses across Wisconsin, Illinois, and Iowa.


23. Goetsch Bucholtz Inc

Goetsch Bucholtz, Inc. is a leading insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage for personal, business and commercial insurance needs. With nearly 100 years of experience, they have a team of trusted providers who help their customers to find the right plan that fits their budget and situation.


Want to find more home insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer comprehensive coverage for homes, vehicles, liabilities, and much more you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!

Get started with Inven
Find companies 10x faster with Inven
Mock-up images of Inven UIGet started
Get Started Today!
See how Inven can help you source deals, find acquisition targets and potential buyers!
Get started

Keep on reading

More articles

Top 20 agribusiness companies in North Carolina Thumbnail
Top 20 agribusiness companies in North Carolina Main
North Carolina's Top 20 Agribusiness Achievers
Discover the top 20 agribusiness companies in North Carolina, from fresh produce giants like Dole Food Company to poultry specialists such as Case Farms, Inc.
Top 19 furniture manufacturing companies in Illinois Thumbnail
Top 19 furniture manufacturing companies in Illinois Main
19 Outstanding Furniture Manufacturers in Illinois
Discover 19 distinct furniture manufacturing companies in Illinois; entities like Stevens Industries and WM. Huber Cabinet Works are inclusive, providing diverse and tailored furnishings.
Top 20 aluminum die casting companies in Indiana Thumbnail
Top 20 aluminum die casting companies in Indiana Main
20 Outstanding Aluminum Die Casting Companies in Indiana
Explore Indiana's top 20 aluminum die casting companies, specializing in advanced and sustainable production. Companies include Ryobi Die Casting, Inc. and Madison Precision Products, Inc..