The auto insurance industry in Missouri plays a vital role in ensuring vehicle owners are adequately covered in the event of accidents or unforeseen events. It encompasses a broad variety of companies, ranging from large nationwide establishments to local agencies. Some of these businesses specialize in unique areas like SR 22 insurance, while others offer a comprehensive spectrum of property and casualty insurance products such as auto, homeowners, renters insurance, and more. As consumer preferences shift toward more personalized services, it's anticipated that the industry will adopt more custom-made solutions and digital innovations to meet these demands.


Top 24 auto insurance companies in Missouri

1. AmShield Insurance

AmShield Insurance Company offers competitively priced property and casualty insurance products such as auto, homeowners, renters, condominium, motorhome, and umbrella insurance. They prioritize integrity, financial excellence, and exceptional customer service.


2. First State Insurance Agency, Inc

First State Insurance Agency, Inc. offers a wide range of insurance products, including auto insurance, homeowner's insurance, life insurance, and personal health insurance. They also have specialized programs for businesses, municipalities, trucking, contractors, and construction companies. With experienced and caring agents, they provide quality insurance solutions and banking services. Proudly serving Farmington, MO, and surrounding areas for over 90 years.


3. Select Insurance Group

Selectsr22insurance.com is dedicated to helping individuals obtain the SR 22 insurance coverage they need at affordable rates. With partnerships with multiple SR 22 insurance companies, their experienced staff simplifies the process, ensuring reliable coverage. They also provide assistance with owner and non-owner FR-44 insurance policies, catering to residents of Florida and Virginia who have been convicted of a DUI.


4. Secure Insurance Group Powered by Impact

Secure Insurance Group is an insurance company that offers a wide variety of services including life insurance, annuities, Medicare, home insurance, auto insurance, and business insurance. They provide competitive rates and personalized plans to help individuals, families, and business owners secure their future and the future of their loved ones.


5. Southwest Agency Inc

Southwest Agency is an insurance agency that has been serving farmers, families, car owners, and companies since 1955. They offer homeowner's insurance, auto insurance, commercial insurance, farm insurance, general liability insurance, and workers' compensation. With a dedicated team of professionals, they prioritize their clients' needs and provide comprehensive insurance coverage at competitive rates.


6. Twin Lakes Insurance Agency

Twin Lakes Insurance Agency is an insurance agency based in Lee's Summit, MO that offers a variety of insurance options to meet the specific needs of individuals and businesses. They provide auto, home, business, life, health, and bond insurance.


7. Mitchell Insurance, INC.

Mitchell Insurance is a company that offers reliable coverage and reasonable rates for auto, life, home, and business insurance. They provide actionable insights to drive businesses further and strive to get the most coverage for the best price possible.


8. Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance

Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance is a company that provides insurance coverage for individuals and businesses in Missouri. They offer a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, life, and small business insurance. With over 200 agents across the state, they provide personalized and professional customer service to their clients. Their mission is to protect what is important to their customers and help them navigate the complexities of insurance.


9. Nixon & Lindstrom Insurance

  • Website: nixonins.com
  • Headquarters: Springfield, Missouri, United States
  • Founded: 1955
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Nixon & Lindstrom Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Springfield, Missouri. They offer personalized insurance policies for individuals and small businesses since 1955. Their services include commercial insurance for large and small businesses, employee benefit plans, and home and auto insurance for individuals. They provide comprehensive coverage and tailored solutions to meet their clients' needs.


10. Shelter Insurance Companies

Shelter Insurance is a mutual insurance company that offers a range of insurance products such as home insurance, auto insurance, farm insurance, and life insurance. They provide coverage to individuals, families, and businesses.


11. AssuredPartners of Missouri

APMissouri.com offers independent coverage options for personal needs, serving high net worth individuals. They provide insurance services such as risk management, loss prevention, claims management, and online services. The company operates as a trusted advisor and risk management partner, consulting with clients to understand their needs and recommending the best combination of coverage and value. They have a team of experienced professionals dedicated to protecting assets and promoting client success.


12. 800 Call-KC

  • Website: call-kc.com
  • Headquarters: Kansas City, Missouri, United States
  • Founded: 1992
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

CallKC is a company that provides insurance services, specializing in multiple risk coverage for homes, automobiles, and personal belongings. They offer protection against theft, fire, explosions, storms, water damage, vandalism, glass breakage, natural and technological disasters.


13. Focus Insurance

Focus Insurance is an independent insurance agency that offers a range of insurance products and services. They provide coverage in ten broad categories, helping customers find the right types and levels of coverage for their specific needs. With a dedicated and knowledgeable team, Focus Insurance offers exceptional service and expertise.


14. Cornerstone National Insurance

Cornerstone National Insurance is an insurance company that offers coverage for homes, autos, and personal belongings. They provide a variety of customizable insurance options to meet the needs of their customers. With their streamlined products and network of independent agents, they aim to provide personalized coverage and exceptional customer service.


15. Veterans United Insurance

Military United Insurance is a licensed insurance company that offers coverage options for home, auto, life, and more. They strive to provide remarkable customer service for veterans and service members in California, helping them find the best coverage at competitive rates.


16. Insurance Store, Inc.

Insurance Store Inc. is an independent insurance agency located in Chesterfield, Missouri. They offer a wide variety of insurance programs to protect homes, businesses, and automobiles. With their top-quality customer service and representation of multiple insurance companies, they provide the best coverage at competitive prices.


17. Freedom Insurance Services, Inc.

Freedom Group is an insurance provider that offers a simplified process for finding the best insurance coverage. They proactively shop top national carriers to provide cost-effective coverage. With dedicated customer support, they prioritize the needs of individuals, families, and businesses.


18. The Insurance Shop

The Insurance Shop is an insurance agency that helps individuals and businesses find the best coverage for their insurance needs. They offer a wide range of insurance policies including home insurance, commercial auto insurance, liability insurance, and more.


19. The Insurancenter

The Insurancenter is an independent insurance agency that has been serving families and businesses in Joplin, MO and surrounding areas since 1895. They offer a wide range of insurance products, including commercial insurance, personal insurance, employee benefits insurance, surety bonding, and a national car wash insurance program.


20. Beimdiek Insurance Agency, Inc.

  • Website: beimdiek.com
  • Headquarters: Carthage, Missouri, United States
  • Founded: 1936
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • Latest funding type: Acquired
  • LinkedIn

Beimdiek Insurance Agency, Inc. is a brokerage firm that provides exceptional service and value to customers. With years of experience, they offer a full range of brokerage services including employee benefits, property and casualty, professional consulting, financial and retirement. They prioritize building long-term relationships with clients, employees, and the community.


21. The Resource Center

The Resource Center is a financial services and independent insurance agency based in Springfield and Branson, Missouri. They provide customized financial strategies, insurance, wealth management, and retirement planning services to individuals and families. They prioritize client needs and offer personalized solutions for insurance, investments, and financial planning. With a team of experienced professionals, they aim to simplify the financial process and help their clients pursue a confident future.


22. Fortner Insurance Services

Fortner Insurance Services provides customized insurance plans to fit the needs of individuals, businesses, and organizations in Springfield, MO. With competitive prices and excellent service, they aim to ensure the best of both worlds for their customers.


23. Goldblatt + Singer

St. Louis Injury Law is a personal injury law firm that helps accident victims hold negligent parties responsible for their actions. They provide legal assistance to clients with a variety of injuries, including broken bones, brain injuries, and spine injuries. The firm offers thorough investigations, evidence collection, and legal representation to give their clients the best chance for a successful personal injury claim.


24. Webb Insurance (Missouri)

Webb Insurance is an insurance agency that offers a wide range of personal and commercial insurance policies, including auto, home, life, recreational vehicle, and liability coverage. They work with multiple insurance companies to provide competitive pricing and a variety of products.


Want to find more auto insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer comprehensive coverage and personalized insurance solutions you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!