The auto insurance industry in Idaho is composed of various companies, specializing in protecting motorists against financial loss in the event of an accident or other types of damage to their vehicles. These companies offer a wide range of insurance products, encompassing auto, motorcycle, recreational, property, health insurance and more. The industry is evolving, with companies adapting their insurance packages to cater to the changing needs of Idaho residents. Emerging trends in the industry predict growth and innovation, driven by the rise of digital insurance platforms, increased product customization and the incorporation of telematics in insurance plans.


Top 25 auto insurance companies in Idaho

1. Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company of Idaho

Idaho Farm Bureau Insurance Company offers a range of insurance products including auto, motorcycle, recreational, homeowners, renters, life, umbrella, health, business, crop, and farm & ranch insurance. They provide financial peace of mind to Idaho families, farms, and businesses by protecting what matters most.


2. Castle Lake Insurance

Castle Lake Insurance is an independent insurance agency that offers a wide range of insurance coverage options to individuals and businesses. With a focus on providing excellent service and finding the best rates, they offer auto, property, business, health, life, and crop insurance.


3. Myriad Benefits

Myriad Insurance is a company that offers a range of insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. They provide comprehensive coverage for various needs including property, health, auto, and liability insurance. With their expertise and personalized approach, Myriad Insurance ensures that their clients are protected financially and have peace of mind.


4. Insur-Mart

Insur-Mart LLC provides insurance products and services to individuals, families, and businesses in Boise, Meridian, and surrounding areas. They offer online quotes, coverage on cars, homes, businesses and health insurances, and have contract with multiple insurance carriers to provide customers with more options than agencies representing only one or two companies.


5. Castle Rock Insurance

  • Website: castlerockidaho.com
  • Headquarters: Burley, Idaho, United States
  • Founded: 2013
  • Headcount: 11-50

Castle Rock Insurance is an insurance company based in Burley, Idaho that offers auto, home, and life insurance policies to their clients.


6. The Hartwell Corporation

The Hartwell Corporation is the largest Employee-Owned Insurance Agency in Idaho, offering professional liability insurance, general liability insurance, property insurance, workers compensation insurance, and auto insurance. They have offices in Idaho Falls, Caldwell, Nampa, and Boise.


7. Mutual Insurance

  • Website: mutualid.com
  • Headquarters: Pocatello, Idaho, United States
  • Founded: 1974
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn

Mutual Insurance Assoc., Inc. is an independent insurance agency that offers a wide range of coverage options from multiple insurance companies. They provide competitive prices, excellent service, and prioritize customer satisfaction. Whether you have a perfect or imperfect history, they find the right coverage with the best company at the best price for you.


8. Kimberling Insurance

Kelly Kimberling Insurance Agency is an insurance provider that offers a wide range of insurance policies, including car, home, life, and business insurance. They work to find the best coverage options at the lowest rates for their clients.


9. Insurance Services Of Idaho

Idaho Insurance for Less is an independent insurance agency serving clients in Idaho and Oregon. They offer personal and business insurance solutions, including auto, home, condo, general liability, workers' compensation, and health insurance.


10. Murray Insurance Inc

Murray Insurance is an insurance and financial services company located in Lewiston Idaho, providing home, auto, property, renters and business insurance policies.


11. Martin Insurance, Inc.

Martin Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Lewiston, ID that provides personal and commercial insurance. They shop the top national carriers to find the best insurance coverage at an affordable price.


12. All Valley Insurance

All Valley Insurance is a provider of insurance policies for both personal and commercial purposes. They offer a variety of coverage options that include auto, home, business, and more.


13. Silver Key Insurance Boise

Silver Key Insurance is an independent insurance agency that offers auto, home, and life insurance policies tailored to the needs of its customers from multiple trusted carriers.


14. Silver Key Insurance, Inc

Silver Key Insurance is an independent insurance agency that has been providing auto, home, business, and health insurance services to the Eagle community and all of Idaho. They work with several of Idaho's most trusted insurance carriers to find the best value for their clients.


15. Midtowne Insurance Agency

Midtowne Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency based in Caldwell, Idaho, serving customers since 1971. They offer a range of insurance products for individuals and businesses, including auto, home, health, and commercial insurance.


16. Mountain States Insurance Group / MSIG Ag Inc

Mountain States Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency providing risk management solutions for homeowners, car owners, farmers, and businesses throughout northern Utah and southern Idaho. With a century of experience, their agents provide personalized coverage for each unique customer and stay ahead in the insurance industry.


17. Kimbrell Insurance Agency

Kimbrell Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Boise, Idaho. They provide high-quality insurance plans for car, home, life, and business at competitive rates.


18. Financial Insurance Group

Financial Insurance Group in Boise, Idaho offers flexible insurance coverage for both personal and commercial customers. Their independent agency ensures that each client gets personalized attention and customer service.


19. Elissa Edmonds - State Farm Insurance Agent

Elissa Edmonds offers Auto, Home, Condo, Renters, Business, Life, and Pet insurance policies with State Farm.


20. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance

myidahoinsurance.com offers insurance products and services for auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, and life insurance in Idaho.


21. Chris Baldwin - State Farm Insurance Agent

Chris Baldwin Insurance Agency is a State Farm Insurance agent providing auto, home, renters, life, pet, and small business insurance in Mountain Home and Garden City, Idaho.


22. Jan Jesberger Insurance

Jan Jesberger Insurance provides a range of insurance services for personal and commercial clients, including home, auto, and liability insurance. They specialize in insurance for classic car restoration businesses and provide guidance to ensure clients' assets are protected.


23. Martinson Insurance

Martinson Insurance Agency provides a variety of insurance services, including auto, home, health, life, business, and farm insurance, as well as annuities, Medicare plans, disability coverage, and long-term care insurance.


24. Fuhriman Insurance

InsureMePlus.com offers a variety of insurance services, including auto, home, commercial, life, umbrella, renters, workers compensation, and toys insurance.


25. Infanger Insurance

Infanger Insurance is an insurance agency offering a variety of insurance policies for vehicles, property, businesses, and life/financial needs.


Want to find more auto insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that offer comprehensive coverage to protect your automobiles you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!