The disability insurance industry in Ohio is comprised of a diverse range of companies, each offering unique and tailored coverage options to cater to different needs and circumstances. From independent insurance agencies to specialized benefit planning firms, these companies provide a variety of solutions including short-and long-term disability, medical, dental, vision, and voluntary coverage. They not only deal with health-related aspects but also offer comprehensive welfare coverage and retirement insurance. As the industry continues to evolve, we are seeing a rise in innovative funding options and a growing emphasis on personalized customer relationships.


Top 22 disability insurance companies in Ohio

1. Benchmark Insurance

Benchmark Insurance is an independent insurance agency providing Employee Benefit Solutions to employers and business owners. They offer coverage for health insurance options, dental and vision plans, and short- and long-term disability insurance. They prioritize building trusted relationships with their clients and have knowledgeable and experienced team members. Benchmark Insurance is based in Westerville, Ohio and serves Central Ohio and the United States.


2. Benefit Plan Alternatives, Inc.

Benefit Plan Alternatives specializes in employee benefit planning including Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability and Voluntary coverage with a philosophy of assisting HR with a smooth transition, solving claims problems for employees, and satisfying the financial demands of C Suite at your company. They offer creative funding options with a partnership with clients in helping them deal with the legislative complexities of navigating the ACA law.


3. Ohio Laborers Benefits

Ohio Laborers Benefits is an insurance and pension provider founded in 1967. They offer comprehensive health and welfare coverage for eligible members, including a PPO network, prescription drug benefits, vision care, hearing aid benefits, accidental death & dismemberment benefits, and short term disability benefits. Retiree insurance is also available. They also provide pension plans and have a range of contractor relations services.


4. Ohio National Financial Services

Ohio National Financial Services is a company that offers various insurance and financial products for individuals and businesses.


5. The Uhl Agency

The Uhl Agency is an independent insurance agency offering comprehensive insurance-based solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. They provide property and casualty insurance products as well as life, health, and disability insurance options.


6. Sheakley Benefit Plans

At Sheakley Benefit Plans, we offer traditional and innovative programs and strategies. We are committed to staying on top of the ever-changing market by continually researching and monitoring products and companies. We do our best to help you protect what you have and build for the future.


7. Armada Risk Partners

Armada Risk Partners is an independent insurance brokerage providing innovative insurance and risk management solutions with a consultative approach.


8. Dempsey & Siders Insurance Agency

Dempsey & Siders Insurance Agency provides insurance services and benefits solutions to clients in Cincinnati and nationwide. They offer personal insurance, business insurance, and health & benefits coverage. Their services include coverage for employee dishonesty, forgery, theft, commercial umbrella policy, employment practices liability insurance, and more. They prioritize client satisfaction and have been serving their clients since 1956.


9. Iori Insurance Agency, Inc

Iori Insurance provides a range of insurance products including life, health, business, and auto insurance.


10. Simon Insurance Agency - Ohio

Simon Insurance Agency provides insurance solutions such as auto, home, life, and commercial insurance to customers in the Eaton, OH, West Alexandria, OH, Greenville, OH areas as well as the surrounding areas.


11. R & L Insurance Group

RandLInsurance.com is an insurance agency providing a range of personal and commercial insurance services. Their expertise includes auto, home, life, renters, and business insurance, as well as financial planning and investment management services.


12. Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency

Advantage Insurance Agency is an insurance company with a focus on providing top-rated insurance carriers for businesses and personal clients. They have a unique process of working with clients to provide organized insurance programs.


13. Maxwell Agency

Maxwell Agency Insurance Services offers personal and commercial insurance products including health, travel, group, personal and commercial insurance. They focus on delivering personalized attention and customer service based on the unique risk profile of each client.


14. The Todd Organization

  • Website: toddorg.com
  • Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1957
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

The Todd Organization is a company that specializes in designing and managing benefit and funding programs for clients since 1957. They offer customized corporate-owned life insurance plans, non-qualified retirement plans, bonus and savings programs, and other creative financing options. Their expertise lies in deferred compensation, executive benefit plans, and asset-liability management strategies.


15. Beam Dental

  • Website: beam.dental
  • Headquarters: Columbus, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 2012
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn

Beam Dental is a dental benefits company that offers innovative, technology-driven solutions for employers and individuals. They provide dental insurance plans with enhanced coverage and access to a nationwide network of dentists.


16. Toledo Electrical Benefits Plans

Toledo Electrical Benefit Plans provides benefits and retirement plans for eligible members in the electrical industry in northwest Ohio and southeast Michigan.


17. School Employees Retirement System

  • Website: ohsers.org
  • Headquarters: Columbus, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1937
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn

OHSERS.org is the official website of the Ohio Department of Insurance, providing resources, information, and services to Ohioans, particularly those enrolled in Medicare. The website offers educational materials, videos, and events related to insurance, retirement plans, and benefits for members of the Ohio School Employees Retirement System (SERS).


18. Mutual Health Services

Mutual Health Services is a full-service third-party administrator that offers customizable health insurance plans. They provide products and services for companies that self-fund their health coverage, including claims cost management and actionable reports. They also offer a customer portal for easy policy access.


19. Medical Mutual

  • Website: medmutual.com
  • Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States
  • Founded: 1934
  • Headcount: 1001-5000
  • LinkedIn

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurance company that offers a range of insurance plans including Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Employer Group plans. They provide coverage for individual and family needs, specializing in health insurance solutions.


20. CAI Insurance Agency, Inc

CAI Insurance is an insurance company that specializes in providing comprehensive insurance solutions. They offer a wide range of insurance products, including business property insurance, liability insurance, workers compensation, and business auto insurance. Their team of experienced professionals helps clients navigate the risks and uncertainties of the insurance industry, offering personalized risk assessments and tailored coverage options.


21. Zito Insurance Agency a Division of Risk Strategies

Zito Insurance is a company that provides insurance services to individuals and businesses. They offer a wide range of insurance policies to protect against various risks and provide peace of mind.


22. Huesman Schmid Insurance Agency

Huesman Schmid Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Cincinnati Ohio. They offer a wide range of insurance services for individuals and businesses, including auto, home, and business insurance. Their experienced staff provides excellent customer service and guidance throughout the insurance process. They are actively involved in the local community and support various charities and organizations to improve the area.


Want to find more disability insurance companies?


If you want to find more companies that provide a wide array of insurance coverages, including disability you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.


With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:


  • Ownership: Which of these are private equity backed? Which are family-owned?
  • Contact data: Who are the owners and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!